Reverse Seared Tri Tip Recipe | GrillinFools (2024)

A tri tip roast, seasoned simply with salt, pepper and garlic and then slow smoked on my pellet grill before putting a beautiful flavor crust with that wicked hot fire on my Santa Maria cooker. The result is that coast to coast pink from this reverse seared tri tip recipe.

Here at GrillinFools.com we LOVE the tri tip. My first, slightly overcooked attempt back in 2011. Three years later, I did tri tip tacos and five years later I did mesquite smoked tri tip tacos for a commercial I did for co*ke that aired on NBC during a NASCAR race. It seems I love tacos as much as I love tri tip. Moreover, tri tip makes for a fantastic sandwich, particularly with chimichurri as a condiment, which was done in late 2022. But the most iconic method, and simplest recipe for cooking tri tip, is the reverse sear method. I decided to back this up and lay that very recipe down without all the rest of the accoutrements.

Reverse Seared Tri Tip Recipe Ingredients

• 2 trimmed tri tips
• SPG seasoning (SPG stands for Salt, Pepper and Garlic)
• 1 ounce grape seed oil, substitute wagyu beef tallow

From the ingredients list it’s pretty obvious that this recipe is pretty basic. Traditional tri tip is not complicated – simple seasoning of salt, pepper and garlic (SPG seasoning) and open fire. To begin with let’s back up and give a little context here.

What is a Tri Tip?

Tri tip is a sirloin roast cut from the very bottom of the primal sirloin cut. It was originally cast off, bound for the grinder for hamburger. The pitmasters of the Santa Maria region of California took those cast offs and thus fed their cowboys and ranch hands high quality protein for very little money. Tri tip is traditionally cooked over red oak which is plentiful in the Santa Maria region of California. This strange triangular cut, weighing in between 1.5 and 2.5 pounds has the grain run two ways making it difficult to slice properly. Being a small roast, it is ideal for reverse searing in a short period of time.

Here are my two trimmed tri tips. These were 1.8 and 1.9 pounds before removing the fat so these are on the smaller side. The fat has been removed in the pic below:

Indeed, leave as much or as little of the fat as you wish. Just make sure to take off the hard, dense fat.

Season both sides with the salt, pepper and garlic (SPG seasoning):

Feel free to apply liberally here. Since we slice this, each slice only has an outer edge of seasoning so go to town.

Don’t forget the edges. Simply dab the edges on the SPG seasoning that missed the tri tip roasts and landed on the cutting board:

How to Reverse Sear

Slow smoking the meat before searing. If the meat is seared first, it won’t take on much smoke when smoking afterward. By smoking first, we infuse that wonderful smokiness and then get the caramelized proteins from the sear. Smoke the meat to within 10F-15F short of the desired doneness, remove the protein from the grill, stoke up the heat to north of 400F and sear to get a nice flavor crust while bringing the meat up that last 10F-15F degrees.

Set the smoker to 225F. Place the seasoned tri tips in the pellet grill (or whatever grill you are using as a smoker) and shove the probe thermometer into one of the sirloin roasts in the very middle:

Even at 225F the tri tip did not take long to get 10F-15F short of our desired doneness of 125-130F. I know some of you are aware of my love for rare steak and are wondering why I’m cooking to medium rare. Because tri tip can be stringy if only cooked to rare. I’m good with medium rare too so this isn’t a problem for me.

After about 45 minutes, the smoked tri tip roasts are 115F and ready to come off the cooker:

Rest it Twice

Now comes for the best tip I can give in this reverse seared tri tip recipe. The normal process of reverse searing is fairly simple: season, smoke, sear, rest, serve. But I’m going to change that up with: season, smoke, REST, sear, REST AGAIN, serve.

I’m going to leave these smoked tri tips on that plate for a long rest. By letting them rest here for quite a while, I can put a fantastic sear on the outside without over cooking the meat. Conversely, if these went straight from the smoker to the sear then I can only sear so much to take them from 115F to 125F-130F. But what if the temp drops back down to room temp? Then I can sear all day and still not overcook! BOOM!

Time to build my fire on my Hooray grill which is a Santa Mara style cooker and oh so appropriate for this reverse seared trip tip recipe.

Here is a traditional tri tip I did on the Hooray Grill.

I busted out some of my Butlerwood stash of smoke wood and sparked up a pile of pecan which pairs wonderfully with both beef and pork:

No Pecan, No Problem

If you don’t have pecan and want to know what proteins pair well with what you have access too, check this extensive list of smoke woods. Additionally, if you are disappointed in what smoke woods are available near you, check out Butlerwood smoke wood. I love this stuff so much that I ordered 1,700 pounds of it. I’m not kidding. This is in my garage:

That’s a 4’X4′ pallet stacked five feet high with post oak on the bottom, hickory in the middle and pecan on the top. There are a couple other varieties in boxes on the very top so I can play with lots of flavor profiles. I can’t park my car in the garage, however I have lots of smoke wood. It’s called priorities!

And here is that Butlerwood in action on my Santa Maria grill:

I slow roasted another tri tip over this wood for the other tri tip recipe I did that I will publish next week.

Here are those wicked hot pecan coals that smell soooooo good:

After a good 45 minutes, the tri tips have gotten a little dark:

These have cooled and come back to room temperature. Or at least to deck temperature on a 65F degree day.

Re-Season to Replace What was Lost on the Smoker

First, I hit them with a little spritz of grape seed oil. Although, any high heat fat will work here. I’m a big fan of wagyu beef tallow as the flavor crust is SICK, but this is a little less messy with the atomizer spray bottle:

Then, a quick sprinkle of SPG seasoning as lot of that seasoning melted into the tri tip while smoking and resting:

Sear, baby sear!

Additionally, give that fat end of the tri tip a sear as well by holding it over the coals with a set of tongs:

Remember, the target temp is 125F-130F. If you prefer more than that, place the tri tips just off the edge of the coals so they don’t continue to sear. In conventional grills, place them on the side of the grill with no coals or a lit burner. Back in the smoker works too. However, for this cook, we are done:

Close enough.

If you prefer a different doneness, let me help with this chart:

Steak Temps

• Rare Steak Temp:120F-125F
• Medium Rare Steak Temp: 130F-135F
• Medium Steak Temp: 140F-145F
• Med. Well Steak Temp: 150F-155F
• Well Done Steak Temp: 160F or more, but seriously, just order the chicken

Finally, after a resting period of 5-10 minutes, it was time to slice. I had planned on getting some overhead shots to show exactly how to slice the tri tip, however I forgot to get those pics. I will cook another one and take proper pics and drop them in here. In the mean time, let’s get to that reveal. And this is the first cut, From the point opposite the long flat side of the triangle, straight across to bisect that flat side.

And a close up:

Coast to coast, BAY-BEE!!!

Alas, the thicker end was coast to coast pink, but the thinner end had some grey banding. That’s the one downfall of the tri tip. With one end so thick and one end so thin, something has to give.

Slicing the rest involves finding the grain in each of those two halves and cutting perpendicular to it:

Plattered on a live edge cutting board:

Reverse Seared Tri Tip Recipe Recap

Simply seasoned, simply smoked, extensively rested, simply seared, rested a bit more and then simply sliced and finally served. It’s not hard to do this. If you can grill a hamburger or a bratwurst, then you can reverse sear a tri tip. This is probably my favorite way to feed a crowd steak for not a lot of money. And I have a bunch of other options there.

If you have any questions or comments about this reverse seared tri tip recipe, feel free to leave them below or send me an email.

And if you could leave us a great review and five stars that would be most appreciated!

Also, you can follow us on ourGrillinFools Facebook page,Instagram, andYouTubefeeds

Recipe Card for Reverse Seared Tri Tip Recipe: